If one tie rod is bad on my 2005 Toyota Camry do I need to replace both of them.

After taking my car into the checked out for a problem in the front passenger tire I was told that the outer tie rod needed to be replaced . one mechanic told me that I could replace one and not have to do both and another mechanic told me that I needed to do both at the same time even though there was nothing wrong with the driver side tie rod. which is correct?

My car has 240000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Experienced mechanics share their insights in answering this question :
Hello. Though it is good to have balance in your steering system and it is good practice to replace parts on both sides at the same time, you do not need to do that. You onlt need to replace the part that is actually faulty. Once it is replaced the vehicle will need to be aligned. If you are going to have this tie rod replaced, consider YourMechanic, as a certified mechanic can come to you to [replace your tie rod] https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/tie-rod-end-replacement

How to Identify and Fix Common car Problems ?

Our sources include academic articles, blog posts, and personal essays from experienced mechanics :

While it may not be absolutely necessary to replace both tie rods at the same time, many mechanics may recommend a varying combination of replacement parts. If you are changing an inner tie-rod, and the outer tie-rod is an original part, it is recommended to change both.
We recommend replacing both the inner and outer tie rod together as a set. You can run into issues like a worn or loose nut, stripped threads, or a worn or torn boot that can cause problems while driving.
When your tie rods go bad, the symptom you`re most likely to experience first is a vibration or shaking sensation in your steering wheel. You may also hear associated clunking and rattling noises, especially when turning the vehicle at low speeds. These sounds are caused by tie rods that are starting to wear out.
There is a test protocol in the factory service manual that is relied on to determine if a tie rod end is “worn out”. Per the protocol, if it turns out that only 1 tie rod end is worn out, then only that one need be replaced and the others can be left alone.
In many vehicles, tie rods connect your steering gear to the steering knuckle. Tie rods are an integral part of your vehicle`s steering system that if worn can cause tire wear and handling problems. That`s why a visual inspection can be worthwhile.
Tie rods can last for several years. In fact, you may never have to replace your tie rods. The conditions you drive in play a large role in the lifespan of tie rods.
The outer tie ends are an integral part of the steering system. With all this movement and stress, they will eventually wear beyond their limit. If an inspection reveals a worn tie rod end, you can replace it yourself. AutoZone has everything you need to do the job right.
Cars will typically have two tie rod ends on each side: one inner tie rod end and one outer tie rod end — four total with a set of two per side.
If a tie rod breaks while driving, the wheel will break free of your steering assembly, and you will completely lose control of the vehicle. This could lead to a fatal accident.
If a tie rod becomes damaged and fails, the effects can range from mild (premature tire wear) to extreme (loss of vehicle control). Read on to learn the symptoms of a failing tie rod end. A damaged tie rod can cause uneven or excessive tire wear.
Unresponsive Steering Wheel

Note: While a worn tie rod is a common reason for unresponsive steering, this issue can also be caused by other steering wheel and suspension issues.

If you hear a loud, high-pitched squeal that sounds like a shriek whenever you turn your car, it may be a sign that the tie rod ends are worn and need to be replaced. There are other potential causes, including ball joints with bad lubrication or a low level of power steering fluid.
A good tie rod, both inner and outer should have either no twist, or a slight twist in both directions as you will see the outer tie rod pivot back and forth allowing this twist. If this joint is extremely loose and requires no effort at all to twist, the joint is going bad.
Remember, tie rods are essential for a smooth ride; if they`re not functioning properly, you will feel it. In this case, you need to do a visual inspection. If you notice that your car`s front end is no longer aligned, it`s a sign that your tie rod might be damaged.
Inner tie rods can be tightened but this is not something that should be done by a professional shop for a customer as it would be considered an improper repair. For a DIYer it can work fine. The tie rod is removed from the steering rack and put into a press and recrimped with a heavy metal sleeve.
The most common problem that affects tie rods are that they tend to get loose and worn out over time. This generally happens when moisture gets inside causing corrosion or when the rubber boot of the rod cracks or deteriorates.
Again, like in the rack-and-pinion system, the steering rack is connected to the tie rods, which are connected to the steering arms. The tie rods are the connection from your steering system to your wheels.
Tie rods can last for several years. In fact, you may never have to replace your tie rods. The conditions you drive in play a large role in the lifespan of tie rods.
Remember, if one of your track rod ends is worn, chances are that the others are close as well. You should replace both to promote even wear and avoid more expensive repairs while extending the lifespan of your tyres.
Tie rods are a crucial component of a vehicle`s steering system, and when they start to go bad, you`ll feel the difference. Bad tie rods should be addressed immediately, and luckily, it`s not a super difficult job!

Relevant Questions and Answers :

the most relevant questions and answers related to your specific issue

If one tie rod is bad on my 2005 Toyota Camry do I need to replace both of them.
ANSWER : Hello. Though it is good to have balance in your steering system and it is good practice to replace parts on both sides at the same time, you do not need to do that. You onlt need to replace the part that is actually faulty. Once it is replaced the vehicle will need to be aligned. If you are going to have this tie rod replaced, consider YourMechanic, as a certified mechanic can come to you to [replace your tie rod] https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/tie-rod-end-replacement

I have a 2002 toyota camry LE engine wich i want to use on a 2004 toyota camry XLE .is my 02 toyota camry engine compatible ?
ANSWER : Hi there. Assuming that both engines are the same size, the compatibility of "fitting" should be OK. However, since this is a service we don’t offer, we’re not best suited to provide the best advice on this. I can tell you that a common problem have with replacing motors is communication with the ECU. In most cases, it will require reprogramming by a specialist in order for all the systems to work correctly.

Can I get cheap outer tie rods to last me one year
ANSWER : If you decide to get tie rods from an aftermarket supplier they should be good enough quality to last more than a year. They should meet or exceed factory specifications.

Tie Rod Replacement
ANSWER : Hi there. I believe what you are hearing from both dealers are what has recently been referred to as "alternative facts". Here is the truth. A suspension alignment is an inspection and adjustment of all the mechanical components that comprise the front end suspension system. Each part needs to be properly "aligned" in order to ensure the tires contact the ground equally for maximum efficiency, handling, braking and performance. The tie rods on ANY vehicle are a part of the suspension system and are often the root cause of a suspension becoming out of alignment. Anytime you replace any suspension component, a suspension alignment SHOULD be completed. So, if the original mechanic completed an alignment on your car and determined the tie rod was damaged and needed repair, the "service" of the alignment check was performed; and should be charged. If it were my shop, I would not have charged for (2) alignments; only one. However, each shop or dealership has different policies. Hope that clarifies the issue.

Can the tie rods on a 2011 Nissan Juke be replaced without replacing the entire power steering system?
ANSWER : The tie rod ends for your vehicle, both the inner and the outer ends, are available for separate purchase. If you bought these tie rod ends yourself from an auto parts store, they’re "roughly" $50 each or $200 in total if you bought all four (your vehicle has a total of four). It would be unusual (indeed, exceptional) for tie rod ends to fail on a Nissan with only 36,000 miles on it. If you have a problem with the car, I suggest you get it evaluated by a TRUSTWORTHY, knowledgeable individual. A vehicle with 36,000 miles on it is frankly a brand new vehicle and to be in need of thousands of dollars worth of repairs would be unusual, excepting a circumstance where the vehicle was in a collision, abused, or otherwise damaged. If you have a steering issue, please simply request a steering system evaluation/diagnostic and the responding certified mechanic will thoroughly evaluate your vehicle, address your concerns and give you the information you need about any required repairs. If you have further questions or concerns, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic as we are always here to help you.

I have a 2010 camry. I just recently replaced the engine with a 2014 camry engine. Now I have Four engine lights on. I replaced on
ANSWER : If you swapped the engine from a vehicle that is 4 years newer than the car is then you are going to have electrical and sensor incompatibilities that may not be able to be fixed by just a few sensor replacements. There were many changes in computer and emission related items between 2010 and 2014 engines. I would recommend having a mechanic like one from YourMechanic come to you and compare the two engines to isolate the possible differences and see if the problem can be fixed.

When replacing the AC Compressor, do I need to replace both expansion valves as well or just the front
ANSWER : Hi there. Anytime you replace major air conditioning system components like the AC compressor, it’s recommended to purchase all supporting hardware and replace it at the same time. AC works as a series of individual components working efficiently together to create cool air that flows into your cabin. As such, if you’re replacing the front expansion valve, it’s a good idea to replace the rear at the same time. This increases overall efficiency of the system, reduces the potential of small component failure and allows the parts you replaced to last longer.

Do i need to replace the receiver drier and/or the expansion valve when replacing the condenser assembly?
ANSWER : Replacing the system drier is absolutely essential. If the system has been open to the atmosphere (due to the leak in the condenser), the desiccant in the drier has been fully saturated with moisture. As far as the expansion valve, replacement is not normally implicated in a leak repair, in your case a leak in the condenser. To justify replacing the expansion valve, there would have to have been a diagnostic performed which proved a fault. If no diagnostic was performed, and there is no evidence of a fault, then it is pointless to replace the valve. But, again, drier replacement is absolutely essential. To add the drier to your order, you can simply add a note to the mechanic in your order and/or add it as a service (you will see a link that you can click on to "add services" or write in specific services). If you have further questions or concerns, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic as we are always here to help you.