Changing spark plug or ignition coils

Was told today by repair shop that I need spark plug or ignition coils replaced. Service person recommended doing spark plugs first but I only have 46000 on my car and from what I have been reading spark plugs are changed at 60,000. He also states that the ignition coil were covered under my maxcare warranty but I would have to wait for check engine light to come on before warranty would cover coils. What should I do??

My car has 46000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Experienced mechanics share their insights in answering this question :
Changing spark plugs at 46000 isn’t necessarily a bad idea, but mostly I say that because it will keep them from seizing to the cylinder head. Most late model cars like yours can run a set of plugs for longer than that. As for the coils, If the car is not misfiring, I don’t see why you would want to change them and neither does the maxcare company. If the car IS misfiring, then the check engine light will come on and it will set misfire codes. So I don’t see why it would be necessary to do it just yet. If you want to get a third opinion on that, you can contact Your Mechanic to have a technician come out to your home or office to check out your BMW and tell you just what it needs.

How to Identify and Fix Common car Problems ?

Our sources include academic articles, blog posts, and personal essays from experienced mechanics :

Some Ladue drivers often wonder how often they need to change the spark plugs in their BMW vehicle. While experts generally recommend replacing them every 30,000 miles, it will vary depending on your specific model.
There is one 2011 BMW 328i spark plug for each engine cylinder, and this part is responsible for kickstarting combustion in each of the cylinders to power the car.
If you`re stock, just use the gap that comes from the factory, which is around 0.03. If you`re stock, just use the gap that comes from the factory, which is around 0.03. They should come pre-gapped but just check to make sure.
Most BMW ignition coils last for more than 140,000 miles. If you frequently push your car`s performance, the lifespan of your coils can decrease significantly. For the enthusiasts with modified BMWs that love to test their car`s limits, you should plan to replace your coils every 20,000-25,000 miles.
NGK Spark Plug, the world`s leading manufacturer of spark plugs, exclusively supplies BMW with the plugs for the car.
So, 328i cars from the E46 and E90 generation will feature six ignition coils, while the newer F30 328i uses only four coils since it is powered by an inline-four engine.
These plugs are pre-gapped at . 044″.
NGK doesn`t recommend adjusting the plug gap more than . 008″ in either direction. Beyond that slight adjustment, the ground electrode and center electrode won`t align properly, hindering spark plug performance and drastically reducing plug life.
Gap: . 032″ (0.8mm)
Whether it`s replacing the single coil mounted separate to the distributor, the HEI coil, a coil pack, or a coil over plug, we`ve proven on more than one occasion that coil upgrades do provide performance benefits including increased power you can see on the dyno.
Ignition coils generally last 80,000 to 100,000 miles. However, as with most vehicle components, certain conditions like the ones below may cause them to fail sooner.
The average cost for a BMW 328i Spark Plug Replacement is between $218 and $350. Labor costs are estimated between $150 and $189 while parts are priced between $68 and $161.
Spark Plug Bmw 3 Series

This is why spark plugs must be replaced every 20,000 to 60,000 miles. When a plug is defective or worn, the engine of your Bmw 3 Series may misfire; consequently, your vehicle could lose power and consume excess fuel.

Relevant Questions and Answers :

the most relevant questions and answers related to your specific issue

Spark plug chaos. Rubber stoppers are preventing the spark plugs from coming out.
ANSWER : Hi there. Try using a pair of small needle nose pliers to pull off the rubber boots from the spark plugs. As you pull, twist the rubber boots to break them free. If you cannot get the rubber boots off, then try using some mineral oil on the boots to aid them off, then clean off the oil with soap and water with degreaser. If you need further assistance with removing the boots from the spark plugs, then seek out a professional, such as one from Your Mechanic, to help you.

Changing spark plug or ignition coils
ANSWER : Changing spark plugs at 46000 isn’t necessarily a bad idea, but mostly I say that because it will keep them from seizing to the cylinder head. Most late model cars like yours can run a set of plugs for longer than that. As for the coils, If the car is not misfiring, I don’t see why you would want to change them and neither does the maxcare company. If the car IS misfiring, then the check engine light will come on and it will set misfire codes. So I don’t see why it would be necessary to do it just yet. If you want to get a third opinion on that, you can contact Your Mechanic to have a technician come out to your home or office to check out your BMW and tell you just what it needs.

Engine light fault. There was a bad spark plug and a failed ignition coil. Replaced both the coil pack or spark plug.
ANSWER : Hi there. If the light is coming on then shutting off and returning on, then if the issue is for the same coil, there could be an issue with the wiring on the coil plug. Check the wiring on the coil plug and see if the wires are split, broken, or burned. If there is nothing wrong with the plug, then the main engine harness has an issue / short and may need replaced. If you need further assistance with your ignition system, then seek out a professional, such as one from Your Mechanic, to help you.

After part replacements, spark plugs do not work – 1996 Lexus LX450
ANSWER : If you have a Check Engine Light on, first check for those codes to determine what engine management thinks is going on. If no trouble code, check the ignition fuse behind the driver side kick panel (carpeted panel at foot level on the left – for left-hand drive vehicles). If the engine is spinning quickly, and doesn’t appear to be meeting any resistance (as a motor with good compression would have), you may have a broken timing belt. If so – STOP, call a professional mechanic, like a certified technician from YourMechanic for help.

I have a dodge ram 1500 4.7- 2013 was changing spark plugs on top side with a 5mm socket socket is stuck help?
ANSWER : Hi there. Although what you are listing above is not necessarily a service we offer, it is possible to have one of our mobile mechanics come to your location to help you with this issue. To start, I would recommend setting up a spark plug removal service, then contacting the customer service sales professional that works with you to explain exactly what you need. When this has happened to me, I bite the bullet and purchase a new spark plug and new spark plug socket, as it’s very difficult to get it unstuck without damaging the socket.

Need to replace bad spark plug & coil pack on Ford Expedition but not sure what else I need besides the plug and coil pack?
ANSWER : Hi There,
I would recommend having an expert from YourMechanic come to your location to take a look at the vehicle to first determine what the cause of the misfire is if this has not already been done. Engine misfires can be caused by many different problems and are generally caused by either a spark or fuel issue or in some cases, a combination of both. Spark related problems generally will result from things like ignition coils, crankshaft position sensor, spark plugs, spark plug wires or ignition modules not working properly. When the misfire results from a fuel related issue, this is commonly related to a lean fuel condition (lack of sufficient fuel supply to the motor). Fuel related misfires can be caused by many different things such as low fuel pressure, faulty or dirty fuel injectors, a faulty O2 sensor, a dirty or failing mass air-flow sensor, a faulty or dirty idle air control valve or a vacuum or intake leak. When the fuel supplied to the combustion chamber is insufficient, this results in an ignition (spark) that is igniting a less than balanced load of fuel and air. This results in a misfire or an explosion in the cylinder that is much less powerful than the other cylinders. This creates a loss of power that resonates throughout the motor additionally causing other problems with ignition and fuel timing. Due to the number of different things that may cause an engine misfire, the quickest and easiest way to diagnose this type of problem is to hook the vehicle up to a scanning tool which will download any potential fault codes that may have registered in the vehicle’s computer as a result of the poor running condition. I would recommend having an expert from YourMechanic come to your location to diagnose your misfiring problem.

If a coil burns out on a 2010 Dodge Dakota, is it advisable to change the spark plugs and ignition wires just because of the age o
ANSWER : Since you have 100,000 miles and if you have not serviced the transmission or tune up items I would recommend having them serviced. A coil can go bad if it has to overcome worn out plugs or wires and is common cause of coil failure.

One ignition coil in 2008 escape has gone bad. Was given a price if $720.00 to replace coil, change spark plugs and wires, do an e
ANSWER : Hi there. The overall quote you received is about average for a local shop or dealership to offer these services. I would highly recommend if you have these services completed, to have them itemize every service they intend to offer, then compare it to the maintenance schedule tool we have on our website.